What is reputation? Reputation is the subjective qualitative belief a person has regarding a brand, person, company, product, or service.
In today’s digital environment, reputation is more important, pervasive, unforgettable, and meaningful than ever. It’s surprisingly easy to neglect, abuse, reject, or even intentionally shred someone's reputation. Building, sustaining, and protecting corporate or personal reputations can be difficult. Reputation damage can happen in minutes, doesn't need to be based on fact, and the blast radius of a reputation scandal can circle the globe within hours.
Also check out the article What is Reputation Management?
And although reputational scandal is at an all-time high, the concept of reputation is largely misunderstood.
The way in which we answer the question will lead us to the very root of reputation, stripped of its symbiosis with social media and devoid of its association with the corporate scandal. Instead, we will understand the very essence of reputation, which will then allow us to approach reputation’s modern manifestation in a fresh and powerful way.
Your reputation matters – a lot. Understanding reputation at its essential core is the only way to build, protect, and enhance your reputation or the reputation of a business.
Be prepared to revolutionize your understanding of reputation and begin the process of creating you reputation in the most meaningful way.
What is Reputation?
Any understanding of reputation begins by answering the question in the title of this article — what is reputation?
Reputation is the subjective qualitative belief a person has regarding a brand, person, company, product, or service.
Let’s unpack the reputation management definition.
Reputation is Subjective
It’s tempting to think that we control our reputations — that we get to define what people think of us and how they respond. And that’s true to a degree. We control one aspect of our reputation, but holistically, reputation is not just who we are or what we do; it’s what people think of who we are and do.
There is a difference between character and reputation. Only the first one can be controlled entirely.
A person or company’s reputation does not depend solely upon what that person or company does. It depends on the person who is perceiving that reputation. In other words, a reputation is an opinion.
You may have read the quote by Jack Milner, “A man’s reputation is the opinion people have of him; his character is what he really is.”
“A man’s reputation is the opinion people have of him; his character is what he really is.”
Although Milner’s quote is intended to amplify the importance of one’s character, it still leaves the uncomfortable truth to be reckoned with: your reputation is at the mercy of other people’s opinions.
It’s important to note that reputation and character are different. The "repute" of an entity (person or thing) is the estimation of how a person or community feels (their sentiment) about a person’s character. Character is a combination of actual traits the entity bears.
Opinions, like many beliefs, are not based on fact. They are, instead, based on feelings, past experiences, cognitive biases, physical wellbeing, the weather, and whether or not someone has had their morning cup of coffee.
There may be objective facts about you as a person, company, or brand. For example, you are a female. Your company has 18 employees. Your brand logo is a buffalo. Whatever. But those objective facts are not your reputation. Reputation goes beyond objectivity into the murky, unpredictable, volatile, and phantasmagoric dimension of subjectivity.
Because this is true — that reputation is more than our identity or actions — we must admit that some aspects of reputation are beyond our control.
Reputation is Qualitative
My definition of reputation has two descriptors — subjective (described above) and qualitative.
Qualitative refers to the fact that reputation is an amalgam of feeling, taste, perception, or hunches. When someone thinks of your reputation, they are not thinking that you are 6’, 2” and weigh 196 lbs. Those are quantitative facts. Instead, they are thinking of the fact that you are empathetic and an intuitive thinker. Those are qualitative understandings. You can’t measure empathy and intuition like you can measure height and weight.
When discussing reputation’s qualitative side, we understand that it has to do with personal qualities like sincerity, pleasantness, forgetfulness, grumpiness, etc.
Reputation thus has much to do with the personality traits or qualities that come to mind when a person thinks of a person, a business, or an organization.
Reputation is a Belief
As mentioned above, reputation is what people believe about a brand, person, company, product, or service. Belief is one of the strongest forces of humankind. The products of belief have built civilizations, created culture, and sparked genocide.
Belief, as it turns out, isn’t always based on fact. Although someone may have an unshakeable confidence that the Loch Ness monster is authentic, that trust may not be reflective of Nessie’s verifiable existence.
Since belief is such a powerful force, it’s easy to realize why reputation matters. Belief dictates behavior. Consumers who believe a company is a scam will not purchase their products or services. A person who thinks that a politician is corrupt will not vote for him. A neighbor who thinks that you are murderous will not befriend you.
Brands, people, companies, products, and services all have reputations.
Reputation isn’t just tied to individuals. Brands have importance as well. So do products and services.
- Barack Obama has a reputation
- The brand, Coca-Cola, has a reputation
- The beverage, Guinness, has a reputation
- Apple’s service, Genius Bar, has a reputation
Based on this definition of reputation, several things stand out:
- Someone’s belief about your reputation cannot be challenged. Belief, remember, is not always based on fact. Although you may be able to prove that someone’s belief is wrong, misguided, or unverifiable, you may not change that person’s belief.
- You can only control part of your reputation. People see; therefore, people opine. You can, in part, control what they see. But you cannot control what opinions they form based on what they see.
- Reputation and visibility are two different things but have a lot to do with each other. Reputation often takes on a life of its own, and it does so as it grows in scope or visibility. A tech startup in a garage may have a very little reputation when it begins, but as it grows in size, its reputation becomes the full-time job of hundreds of employees and the all-out obsession of thousands of fans. As the visibility of a reputation increases, so does reputational risk.
- Perception is reputation. Reputation is what people perceive it to be. If you are an ax murderer but hide your misdeeds and display instead extravagant philanthropy, you may have an outstanding reputation. Your publicized philanthropy doesn’t change who you are — an ax murderer. But it does change what people perceive you to be. Perception, therefore, is your reputation.
Let’s face it. Reputation is complicated. Its definition may be straightforward, but its manifestations are labyrinthine. Reputation shapes how people behave, what people buy, how people think, and why people act the way they do.
This reality leads us to the second consideration of this article — the importance of reputation.
Why is Reputation Important?
Reputation is important. That much should seem obvious. But why? What are the advantages of having a sterling reputation over, say, having an abysmal reputation? Does it matter in the grand scheme of things — wealth, health, and the pursuit of happiness?
As it turns out, yes. It matters a lot. Wealth? Check. Health? Yes. Pursuit of happiness? Definitely. Reputation is the single most important arbiter of an individual’s fulfillment and a business’s profitability. It’s that important.
To answer this question specifically, I’ll address first the importance of reputation for people and then the importance of reputation for businesses.
The Importance of Reputation for Individuals
Reputation is important for individuals because a favorable reputation gets us what we want in life— safety, friends, self-esteem, and happiness.
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, a theory in motivational psychology, states that human motivation begins at the most basic level with our physiological needs — food, water, rest, etc. When those needs are fulfilled, we seek to fulfill other needs such as security and safety. Beyond this, humans seek to satisfy psychological desires — love, intimacy, and prestige.
It’s at this psychological need level where reputation comes into play. A good reputation delivers self-esteem, achievement, meaning, and realizing one’s potential.
In summary, a reputation is essential because a good reputation provides human fulfillment.
The Importance of Reputation for Businesses
In a business context, reputation is just as important, but the endgame differs. Most business-minded people concur that the purpose of a business is to maximize profit, a la the Friedman Doctrine.
Assuming that a business’s goal is profit, how does reputation serve that goal? It’s simple. Businesses with a good reputation make greater profits. There’s a relatively simple way to prove this. Using Yelp star ratings as a reputation metric, Harvard researchers have determined that higher star ratings on Yelp predict higher revenue.
This is just one example of the significance of a good business reputation. There are legion ways that businesses and individuals metricize and display their reputation. Consumers respond to that reputation by making buying decisions for or against the company.
Some say that reputation isn’t merely important for a business’s revenue; it’s essential for that business’s very existence. According to Business in Focus Magazine, “the reputation of a business is essential to its survival.”
As a case in point, the conflagration of a business like Enron can be associated with a reputational crisis. Enron simply could not effectively manage the massive blow to their company’s reputation.
Without a positive reputation, there’s no such thing as a healthy company.
The Importance of Reputation in the Relationship between Individuals and Businesses
There’s another way to look at reputation. People and businesses interact with other people and businesses based on how they want to shape their reputation.
Customers, as individuals, are interested in upholding their reputation when they patronize businesses or engage with other individuals. For example, an individual may want to protect her reputation as a kind humanitarian by not doing business with a restaurateur who serves meat that has been raised in inhuman conditions. Another individual may vociferously oppose a politician he thinks has a poor reputation because that individual is interested in upholding his reputation.
Reputation, then, is a two-way street. We serve our reputation based on the reputation we hold of other individuals or businesses.
We’ve considered the importance of reputation for individuals and businesses. Still, the importance of reputation can be extrapolated to groups, politicians, business leaders, charities, special interest groups, families, nations, ethnic groups, demographic groups, generational divisions, political parties, brands, products, and services. Nearly every organization has a reputation. And that reputation is one of the most important attributes about them.
To reiterate the importance of reputation, keep these points in mind:
Reputation is built on belief; beliefs are powerful things.
In the section above, I made the point that reputation is a belief. Don’t underestimate the power of belief. Beliefs dictate behavior, and the belief in a reputation is a force to be reckoned with.
Reputation takes years to build.
Warren Buffet’s well-known quote is “It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. If you think about that, you’ll do things differently.”
It sounds a bit discouraging, especially if you’re on the receiving end of a reputational crisis. However, his statement, gleaned from years of business experience, is true and highlights the importance of reputation. Something that takes that long to build has value and significance.
News, especially news about reputation, can spread rapidly.
It’s cliche to say that news spreads fast. We know that. We tweet. We swipe. We tap. We message. However, in the context of reputation, the news is poised to spread especially fast.
Much of reputation management deals in the arena of personal information and rumors, both of which have remarkable alacrity at making the rounds in a social network. In one scholarly study on rumors, researchers simulated a rumor spread on Twitter and postulated that “a rumor started at a random node of the Twitter network on average reaches 45.6 million of the total of 51.2 million members within only eight rounds of communication.”
A story about Tiger Woods’ fall from grace is likely to spread far more rapidly than news of a corporate merger. The Tiger Woods story is personal, and we are interested in people. Needless to say, personal stories with a macabre, prurient, or devastating tincture are even more inclined towards viral dissemination.
News doesn’t have to be true to go viral. Ten days was all it took for a reputation-angled rumor to circle the globe — in this case, news about Macron’s sexual orientation.
And it wasn’t just in Macron’s motherland of France that the news permeated headlines. It went global.
Who’s to blame? Everybody. And nobody. The World Economic Forum points out that “false news travels faster than true stories” and asks the whodunnit question. Three MIT scholars responded: “Falsehood defuses significantly farther, faster, deeper, and more broadly than the truth, in all categories of information, and in many cases by order of magnitude,” The statistics paint the picture:
This factoid serves to emphasize the meta point: Reputation is important. Due to the nature of news, the dissemination of information, and our human tendency to become conduits for the most exciting news, anyone’s reputation is a single tweet away from obliteration.
News about reputation can be permanent.
There’s a cruel irony about the durability of reputation. No reputation remains unchanged. But the news that affects that reputation never dies.
Even posthumously, a person’s reputation still fluctuates, as history shows us. The once-pristine reputation of the founding father, Thomas Jefferson, has gone from triumphant to complicated throughout a few studies and the publication of popular historical nonfiction.
Even though your reputation is subject to change without notice, there is no erasing the news about your reputation. This is especially true in the digital age, where information simply doesn’t go away.
Even in non-digital contexts, “news” persists through hearsay, rumor, speculation, and word-of-mouth. Your character, conduct, and actions may be impeccable, but if someone does so much as asks the wrong question, your reputation could be in trouble.
The key thing to keep in mind is that reputation matters. A lot. Whatever your role, industry, or current reputational status, your reputation is one of the most important things about you or your business.
What is Reputation Capital?
We typically think of capital as monetary assets of some form or another. “Money makes the world go round,” right? Under careful consideration, that’s only partly true. And financial capital is only one type of capital.
Reputation capital is arguably more important than financial capital. Which came first, the reputation that allowed a business to earn financial capital or the financial capital that allowed the company to build a reputation? Put that way, it would seem that a corporate reputation has a primary significance regarding a business’s financial success. Reputation capital first. Financial capital second.
This truth can be traced down to the personal level. When an entrepreneur goes to raise money for her venture, how does she gain the trust of the investors? Sure, she needs a solid business plan, but she also needs a solid personal reputation. Her reputation capital allows her to raise the funding that contributes to establishing a business.
But what is reputation capital? Where does it come from? What is it comprised of? Yes, it matters, but to whom and why?
For the sake of definition, let’s work with this:
Reputation capital is the value of the intangible assets of a business, such as reviews, word of mouth, brand identity, and stakeholder trust. Reputation capital can increase the perceived value of products and services, stock price, and company valuation.
Reputation capital makes the world go round. But surprisingly, few people are aware of how it works, what it is, and what to do about it. Sure, the phrase itself makes logical sense. We know about reputation; we know about capital. Reputation capital.
But how does it work? As I unpack this definition, you will understand reputation capital deeper. And once you finish perusing this article section, you’ll clearly understand the power of reputation capital in today’s world and what you should do about it.
Reputation capital is intangible.
Some assets like land, buildings, or machinery are physical assets. Reputation capital is not a physical asset. Plus, it’s not even quantitative! This is one of the reasons why a discussion of reputation capital tends to falter from the start. We’re not discussing a thing as much as we are talking about a lot of different non-things.
So, instead of asserting its intangibility, I’ll explain what reputation capital is comprised of:
Ratings and Reviews
Although reputation capital is an intangible and qualitative value assessment, it has quantitative measurements. At least we try to give it numbers. Chances are, you’ve participated in the crowdsourced attempt to quantitatively assess a brand’s reputation capital by rating the business.
These reviews cost nothing. Businesses don’t (and shouldn’t!) pay for them. Customers don’t receive any compensation for them. There is nothing that physically exists around these reviews unless perhaps it’s a “Review us on Yelp!” sign at the cash register.
Why do businesses place so much emphasis on getting a five-star rating then? Why do they moan over the single one-star rating that destroyed their perfect five? Because these ratings are a powerful and quantifiable form of reputation capital that translates into greater revenue.
Ratings and reviews are everywhere. You can’t take an Uber ride without rating your driver. You can’t Google Map a business without being requested to rate it after you leave. You can’t get off the phone with your credit card company without being asked to rate your agent's service. You can’t close out a Google Hangout without being asked to rate the quality of the call. Whether you’re an eBay seller, an Amazon product, or a Reddit troll, reviews, ratings, and karma is everywhere.
Tangible, no; quantifiable, yes. And important? Absolutely.
Brand image is what comes to people’s minds when they think of your brand. You shape your personality, refine your communication, define your characteristics, and select a position. And to what end? You are building reputation capital.
Brand image is a driving force in reputation capital. Within the brand's ecosystem is the domain of brand management, which allows a company to increase prices, dissociate from other brands, or capitalize on a certain market. Brand equity increases or decreases based on the relative value of the brand’s position in the market.
These are all intangible elements of a business but are each relentlessly tied to revenue.
Customers place their own value on a product or service, and their value attribution has little to do with the actual cost of the product. Instead, their perceived value is formed through emotion, connection, and feeling. When a customer exchanges $1,500 for one ounce of Hermès 24 Faubourg, what are they paying for?
The cost of harvesting the jasmine, Tiare flower, patchouli, ylang-ylang, vanilla, ambergris, sandalwood, or iris? Or the beautifully etched bottle? Probably not. Although the production of the Hermès perfume is undoubtedly costly, the customer is instead willing to pay for the prestige of the perfume, the way it makes her feel, and the attention she receives when she uses it.
The perceived value may be intangible, but as part of reputation capital, it has a pronounced economic impact on the value of the brand as a whole.
Trust is a core component of reputation. As one Forbes contributor points out, if you lose trust, you also lose reputation. If you lose reputation, you lose trust. If you lose one, you lose both. They are inseparable.
A scholarly study published in the Journal of Product & Brand Management asserted that “trust is viewed as the cornerstone as well as one of the most desirable qualities in any relationship.” Consumers do not do business with companies that they do not trust. Experience in personal relationships corroborates this. Trust, even from a neuroscientific standpoint, comes first, then a relationship.
Trust, as a component of brand capital, is not just desirable. It is essential if a brand is to survive.
Although it’s been criticized as useless business jargon, the concept of a thought leader is meaningful, especially in the realm of reputation capital.
Content marketing is one arena in which brands have asserted thought leadership. The marketing tactic gained momentum in early 2012, and its importance has steadily increased.
Now, five years later, startups and latecomers to the world of content marketing are astonished at how difficult it is to gain a foothold in Google’s search results. A business cannot simply start a blog, write a few pieces, and expect to gain a massive audience.
There’s SEO to consider, keywords to research, algorithms to understand, backlinks to earn, and a myriad of other complex factors that contribute to the success of online content marketing. The entire field of online reputation management must grapple with these complexities to protect, refine, and repair the reputations of businesses and public figures.
Thought leadership, however, is still essential. Thought leadership is what allows a business to prove its know-how and to earn the trust of its customers.
Reputation capital is an asset.
At this point, it’s apparent that reputation capital is a massive asset to any business. It is impossible to conceive a successful business without some reputational capital. Like any business asset, it is what allows the company to hold value, do business, and earn profits.
It’s important to keep in mind that, as an asset, reputation capital is all about value. It drives the financial goals of the company. Reputation capital possessed financial ramifications. A deficit of reputation capital contributes to a financial deficit of the company. A surge in reputation capital provides an increase in profits.
Reputation capital is comprised of disparate things, but forms a cohesive, powerful, and unstoppable force for good or for ill.
The Benefits of a Good Reputation
There is nothing more important than reputation to the success of a business. Hiring the right people, creating the correct culture, designing the right brand visuals — all of these seem trivial when compared to the issue of reputation.
I cannot overstate this: Reputation is important.
In an article from the Interaction Design Foundation, Rikke Dam writes, “reputational capital….is the most vital asset any of us can own as business entities.
Rachel Botsman, in a 2012 TED Talk, says, “Reputation capital creates a massive positive disruption in who has power, influence, and trust.”
The greater you value reputation, the more you will understand how it permeates every aspect of an organization. Although hiring the right people, creating the correct culture, and designing the right visuals are minor issues when compared to reputation, they nonetheless play a role in forming your company’s reputation.
In fact, everything you do, every press release you syndicate, every person you hire, and every blog article you publish has some influence on your brand’s reputation. As information travels at the speed of light, as negative rumors diffuse faster than neutral fact, and as a single tweet shatters reputations, today’s brands cannot afford to overlook reputation.
What is reputation? It’s your most valuable asset as an individual or business. It is who you are, regardless of your character. It’s worth obsessing over. It’s worth whatever attention you choose, and probably more.